Top 10 Must-Try Dishes in St. Augustine

St. Augustine isn’t just known for its rich history and stunning architecture; it’s also home to a vibrant culinary scene. Whether you're a foodie on a mission or a visitor looking to indulge, these ten must-try dishes will give you a true taste of the Ancient City.

1. Minorcan Clam Chowder
   A St. Augustine staple, this spicy tomato-based chowder is infused with datil pepper, a signature local ingredient. Try it at The Floridian or Catch 27 restaurant for an authentic experience.
2. Fried Shrimp Crispy, golden, and oh-so-delicious!
   St. Augustine’s proximity to the Atlantic means fresh seafood is a must. O'Steen's Restaurant is famous for their fried shrimp, served with tangy cocktail sauce and hushpuppies. Also try St. Augustine Seafood Company and their amazing dipping sauces!!
3. Datil Pepper Hot Sauce
   Unique to the region, the datil pepper packs a sweet heat that enhances everything from wings to tacos. Be sure to grab a bottle at local markets or sample dishes featuring this fiery favorite. Datil B Good and Minorcan Mikes are a must try!
4. Conch Fritters
   A Caribbean-inspired treat, conch fritters are savory, spiced dough balls filled with tender conch meat. Enjoy these at DJ's Clam Shack and Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grille for a flavorful starter.
5. Cuban Sandwich
   This pressed sandwich, loaded with roasted pork, ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard, offers a satisfying blend of savory and tangy flavors. Make a special stop at Paladar Cuban Eatery! You won't be disappointed!
6. Grouper Sandwich
   For a taste of Florida’s coastal cuisine, don’t miss a blackened or grilled grouper sandwich. Sunset Grille on Anastasia Island is a top pick for this local favorite.
7. Spanish Tapas
   St. Augustine’s Spanish heritage shines in its tapas offerings. Enjoy small plates like patatas bravas, gambas al ajillo, and jamón ibérico at spots like Columbia Restaurant.
8. Empanadas
   For a quick and delicious bite, grab a warm, flaky empanada stuffed with savory fillings. The Spanish Bakery & Cafe is a great stop for these handheld delights.
9. Best Tacos (Just because...)
   Local favorites include Tacos My Blessing, Burrito Works, Mojos Tacos and Osprey Tacos! Pair them with a local beer from one of our many amazing breweries! List to follow :) 
10. Key Lime Pie
    A Florida classic! This tart and creamy dessert is a must-try in St. Augustine. St. Augustine Fish Camp and Raintree Restaurant offers a decadent version with a buttery graham cracker crust.

Bonus Tip: Don’t forget to explore St. Augustine’s lively farmers' markets, where you can sample fresh produce, artisan foods, and local specialties. Whether you’re a seafood lover, spice seeker, or dessert devotee, St. Augustine’s culinary treasures are sure to delight. Bon appétit!